A new question is answered every 9 seconds

Weight gain on diet soda and clean white-free diet

Resolved Question:

I was hospitalized 18 months ago and had emergency surgery. I lost about 10 lbs in hospital. 18 months later I have regained weight, although I eat a pretty clean, white-free diet and work out 3+ days a week. Can my diet soda consumption ( 3+ per day ) alone have made me regain weight?


Category: Family Physician-GP

Ask Your Own Question

Category: Sexually Transmitted Diseases(STD)Specialist
Dr. Deepu Sebin Sebastian is online now

Expert:  Dr. Deepu Sebin Sebastian replied 4 Days.

Hello,

Thank you for asking your query at DoctorSpring.

No diet soda consumption alone is not the cause of this weight gain. The weight gain from diet soda should be minimal as the calories are less in it. A rebound weight gain can be expected even with normal calorie intake in case of rapid weight loss. I would like to know a typical day's diet of yours to comment more. You can reply as a followup. Also (1) do you have any current medical illness (2) What was the surgery done and indication?

Thank you
Dr.DSS


Patient replied :

I realize from a calorie standpoint it wouldn't not be responsible for weightgain, but are you of the opinion that aspartame can cause metabolic syndrome or interfere with normal insulin levels, or that the carbonation can cause overall body bloat? No illness currently, I had a hemicolectomy ( 8 inches of dead bowel ) and for no apparent reason. :-)


Expert:  Dr. Deepu Sebin Sebastian replied 3 Days.

Hello,

No there is no evidence to say Aspartame can cause metabolic syndrome or interfere with normal insulin levels or cause any 'significant' changes in body metabolism. There are many claims available online, but they are not backed by solid facts and evidence.

It is true that Aspartame will not result in any major weight loss (if you were taking it for that purpose). But it is unlikely that it will cause any weight gain either. And no way a major weight gain.

Your weight gain is most probably due to body's adaptive response due to the weight loss (negative nitrogen balance to positive). Anabolic steroids in body and hormones play a part in this. Even if you are taking less than normal calories per day.

Hope this helps
Please feel free to ask followup questions.
Thank you


Patient replied :

Yes, I appreciate your responses and wonder if you would just explain "negative nitrogen balance to positive". I just enjoy knowing how the human body works. After that I shall leave you along about this. :-) Thank you so much!


Expert:  Dr. Deepu Sebin Sebastian replied 2 Days.

Sure !

Please allow me to quote this "Nitrogen Balance = Nitrogen intake - Nitrogen loss
Blood urea nitrogen can be used in estimating nitrogen balance, as can the urea concentration in urine.
A positive value is often found during periods of growth, tissue repair or pregnancy. This means that the intake of nitrogen into the body is greater than the loss of nitrogen from the body, so there is an increase in the total body pool of protein.
A negative value can be associated with burns, fevers, wasting diseases and other serious injuries and during periods of fasting. This means that the amount of nitrogen excreted from the body is greater than the amount of nitrogen ingested.[2] "

-- Now post surgery you have might gone into a kind of positive nitrogen balance. That means body will go into conserving or rebuilding mode. Conserve as much as possible (Nitrogen is mainly derived from protein, but all the nutrients are conserver. Nitrogen is more an index for this)

Simply put your body was able to extract more from the given nutrients. (Ever wonder why some women put on weight post pregnancy even after all the milk feeding and dieting ?- This is the reason).

Hope I am clear.
Thank you


Dr. Deepu Sebin Sebastian
Category: Sexually Transmitted Diseases(STD)Specialist
Experience: 
MD, Internal Medicine - Stanley Medical School
Medical School - MBBS - Govt. Medical College, Kottyaam

Diagnostic Prediction - Stanford School of Medicine
Received Specialty training in Critical Care, Cardiology, Neurology, Gastroenterology, Nephrology from Stanley Medical College and in Endocrinology, Rheumatology.

Hematology and Geriatrics from Madras Medical College.
Dr. Deepu Sebin Sebastian and 4 other Medical Specialists are ready to help you

Make informed and better medical decisions.

We believe that getting medical questions answered and getting qualified opinions from certified Doctors should be easier.



Specialists from
UK, US, Ind,
Aus & NZ


48000+ consults
in 2015


98.1% Satisfied
users


MEDNET Board,
100% Satisfaction
guarantee

How it works


  • Submit question, upload files, if any
  • Consult is assigned to a specialist
  • Doctor replies, Mean response time: 2 hours
  • Intimation by email, ask follow-ups

Recommendations based on

About DoctorSpring.com

Doctor Spring is a novel online Doctor consultation platform where you can get your medical questions answered by leading Doctors. Just Submit your question and rest assured that you will consult a Doctor easily. Once you submit the question, the Doctor from the concerned specialty will reply within hours. You can always ask more questions or add details with follow-up question options and make it an online doctor chat. You may use this service to consult a specialty or for getting medical second opinion. All paid services come with a MEDNET quality assurance and 100% money back guarantee.

DoctorSpring in News

News

Make informed and better medical decisions.